During a five month investigation into large-scale animal cruelty complaints about properties owned by or associated with local rancher Raymond Frank Christie, Humboldt County Sheriff’s deputies observed bovine bones and carcasses in/near waterways, as well as, areas on the properties where cattle were being contained with little to no feed or grass. These observations validated community complaints that serious violations were taking place on the properties.From the Humboldt-Del Norte Cattlemen's Association:
On Monday, March 19, 2018, the Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office served search warrants at four northern Humboldt County properties associated with Christie, with assistance from the following agencies:
Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office
United States Bureau of Land Management
United States Department of Agriculture
California Department of Food and Agriculture
California Department of Fish and Wildlife
Humboldt County Code Enforcement
Humboldt County Department of Health and Human Services Hazardous Materials Division
Humboldt County Animal Control
Humboldt County Drug Task Force
During the service of the warrants, personnel located approximately 250 to 300 deceased cows, some of which Christie had heaped into large piles approximately 10 feet high near an excavator; others were located laying in/near waterways. Personnel also found a large number of cows contained in small or insufficient corrals and many malnourished animals.
Further violations found included:
Moving dairy cattle without official ID tags
Removal of Brucellosis tags
Removal of state livestock back tags
Bringing cattle into California without veterinary inspection certificates or ID tags
Improper disposal/storage/removal of solid waste
Improper animal keeping
Illegal development within a streamside management area
Cannabis permit violations
Improper/illegal disposal of biohazard waste
Building code violations
Additionally while on the properties, the California Department of Fish and Wildlife discovered the following violations:
Twenty-one violations of disposal of a carcass within 150 feet of a state waterway
Seven violations of discharging sediment into state waterways
Five violations of placement of refuse within 150 feet of a state waterway
One violation of abandoned motor vehicle in a state waterway
Eight violations of substantial alteration of bed and banks of a stream without a permit
Three unpermitted stream crossings
Humboldt County Animal Control found the following violations on the properties:
Five violations of dogs kept in unsanitary conditions
Eight violations of dogs without water
Five violations of inadequate space for dogs to move freely
Four violations of primarily housing a dog on wire flooring
Violations found by the Humboldt County Animal Control were corrected on scene and the dogs were left in the care of a responsible party. The California Department of Food and Agriculture has placed 179 head of cattle on hold for repossession pending further investigation. A plan to care for the remaining livestock owned by Christie is still being developed.
Based on the evidence located, the Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office arrested Christie on the following charges:
• PC 597(a) – Animal cruelty
• PC 597(b) – Causing an animal to be cruelly killed
• PC 597.1 (a) – Failure to provide proper care to an animal
• FG 5652 – Disposal of a carcass within 150 feet of a state waterway
Christie was booked into the Humboldt County Correctional Facility with bail set at $25,000.
The California Department of Fish and Wildlife as well as other involved state agencies will be requesting additional charges as this investigation continues.
Anyone with information for the Sheriff’s Office regarding these cases or related criminal activity is encouraged to call the Sheriff’s Office at 707-445- 7251 or the Sheriff’s Office Crime Tip line at 707-268- 2539.
“The scene described at Mr. Christie’s property is horrific and disturbing. Animal abuse
in all circumstances is indefensible and should never be tolerated. If the alleged
accusations are accurate it is clear a crime was committed. Anyone convicted of these
crimes or any animal abuse should be punished to the greatest extent possible. While
some may try to use this isolated incident to condemn all ranchers I assure you this is not reflective of how myself or hundreds of other ranchers throughout Humboldt County
raise and care for our animals. We will continue to use our collective voice to condemn
all animal cruelty and continue to promote the highest standards of animal care”.
Ray Christie is not a member of our Humboldt & Del Norte Cattlemen’s Association.
Humboldt & Del Norte Cattlemen’s Association