Arts + Scene » Screens

The Sucker's Club

It Chapter Two sinks




IT CHAPTER TWO. When I realized I would have to wait two years between It and It Chapter Two, I was disappointed. The first movie, released in 2017, was tone-perfect in how it portrayed the first half of Stephen King's lengthy novel about childhood friends battling a supernatural clown for the soul of their small Maine village, even if it took some liberties with the book's plot. I wondered if waiting until 2019 to reunite with the Losers Club would dilute some of my enthusiasm. It did not but I now realize that the disappointment I felt at the wait was instructive in preparing for this dismal sequel.

If you're a reader of King's, you know that the most horrifying parts of his work often aren't the haunted cell phones or homicidal cars, but the human cruelty that pads the pages between rattles, groans and screams. In this vein, the movie starts with a daisy chain of trauma: a hate crime, domestic violence and suicide that, while all true to the book, do little to move the plot forward, leave the perpetrators unpunished and the victims underdeveloped. King seems to enjoy drawing contrasts between the ugliest impulses of human nature and real monsters, but, in the hands of director Andrew Muschietti and screenwriter Gary Dauberman, these scenes are just the opening blows in the long beating of a horse that's dead within a half hour of the opening credits.

Don't blame the actors. Although none of the ensemble cast was given quite enough to work with in terms of dialogue, they did a great job of seeming like true friends from the time they're reunited over (spoiler) a plate of possessed fortune cookies. Bev (Jessica Chastain), Bill (James McAvoy) and Ben (Jay Ryan) make a believable love triangle, although the chemistry is due almost entirely to Chastain's trademark smolder. One wishes she were given more to do in this movie than sit at a low burn and scream believably, but the source material didn't provide much opportunity for that. (Stephen King's writing of female characters has always been unsatisfying to me.) Mike (Isaiah Mustafa) is almost given too much to do, as narrator, demi-protagonist and Keeper of the Mythos, and he executes everything so well it's doubly frustrating that he was sidelined as protagonist in favor of Achingly Average White Guy McAvoy. That said, in every ensemble cast someone invariably wrecks the curve and in this case it was Bill Hader, playing Richie "Trashmouth" Tozier. Hader is in his element playing a wisecracking coward with a secret in his past. (A secret that was one of Dauberman's liberties that worked.) James Ransome, playing Eddie Kaspbrak, was a little one-note but he made a great foil to Hader. And the alien-faced Swede Bill Skarsgård made a welcome return as Pennywise. He could have let the fiendish makeup and costuming do the heavy lifting for him, but it's truly Skarsgård's voice, undulating between a trill and a croak, that terrifies.

Three hours should have been the right amount of time for this movie, which requires exploration of characters' backstories, their evolving relationship dynamics and the mythos and undoing of Pennywise, but it drags. The mythos is handled quickly using a Magical Native American subplot that should make us all uneasy. The backstories (handled in flashbacks with the welcome return of several of the child actors from the first movie) are great — easily the best part of the film. It is, ironically, the jump scares that make this movie feel so long and awful. Dauberman is a veteran of the modern horror canon, having directed two recent movies about a haunted doll and another about an evil immortal nun. It Chapter Two seems to have borrowed scary tropes from every horror film made in the last 20 years (as well as some mythos from Harry Potter, of all places) and it piles jump scare upon jump scare so relentlessly they become numbing. Many of the scares are gross instead of startling. By the film's third act, I'd stopped murmuring, "Don't go in there" and begun saying, "Oh for heaven's sake, just hurry up and get in the sewer already so we can get this over with." R. 169M. BROADWAY, FORTUNA, MILL CREEK, MINOR.

Linda Stansberry lives in Eureka and writes fiction and nonfiction in her free time. She prefers she/her pronouns. Just before watching this movie she got a traffic ticket, which may have influenced her review. She still suggests you wait until it comes out on DVD.

See showtimes at or call: Broadway Cinema 443-3456; Fortuna Theatre 725-2121; Mill Creek Cinema 839-3456; Minor Theatre 822-3456; Richards› Goat Miniplex 630-5000.


GIVE ME LIBERTY. A comedy about a road trip to a funeral with a Russian boxer, some senior citizens and a young woman with ALS, whose medical transport is taken over for the ride. 110M. MINIPLEX.

THE GOLDFINCH. A boy who's orphaned by a bombing at MOMA impulsively steals a painting from the rubble. Starring Nicole Kidman, Finn Wolfhard and Sarah Paulson. R. 149M. BROADWAY, FORTUNA, MILL CREEK.

HUSTLERS. In the club with JLo, Constance Wu and Julia Stiles making it rain with Cardi B and Lizzo in a comedy about strippers ripping off some Wall Street dudes, which is the economic plan I've been waiting for. R. 109M. BROADWAY, MILL CREEK.

LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING (2003). Fun fact: The extended edition's running time is how long it actually takes to walk to Mordor. R. 252M. BROADWAY.

SPIRITED AWAY (2001). Hayao Miyazaki's animated adventure about a witch, a dragon and a supernatural spa. PG. 125M. MINOR.


47 METERS DOWN: UNCAGED. More sharks, I guess? And no cages? PG13. 89M. FORTUNA.

ANGEL HAS FALLEN. Gerard Butler reprises his endless role as the president's (Morgan Freeman) bodyguard, this time framed by baddies. R. 121M. BROADWAY, MILL CREEK.

THE ANGRY BIRDS MOVIE 2. More birds vs. pigs with Jason Sudeikis, Leslie Jones and Josh Gad. FORTUNA.

DORA AND THE LOST CITY OF GOLD. Teen Dora (Isabela Moner) goes exploring to save her folks. With Danny Trejo and Benicio Del Toro. PG102M. FORTUNA.

FAST & FURIOUS PRESENTS: HOBBS AND SHAW. A Fast and the Furious spin-off with an unlikely alliance. Is it OK for me to root for the bad guy (Idris Elba) in this one? PG13. 134M. BROADWAY.

GOOD BOYS. A raunchy, funny, surprisingly gentle coming-of-age movie about a trio of pre-teen besties trying to get to a party while beset by angry teen girls. Jacob Trembley, Keith L. Williams and Brady Noon. R. 89M. BROADWAY, MILL CREEK.

HONEYLAND. A documentary about a beehunter in rural Europe and the visiting itinerant beekeepers whose methods conflict with hers. 90M. NR. MINOR.

THE LION KING. An impressive CG remake with a star-studded cast, but all the technical achievements and orchestrated moments lack a little life. Starring Donald Glover, Chiwetel Ejiofor and Beyoncé (please don't tell her we didn't love it). PG. 118M. BROADWAY.

ONCE UPON A TIME ... IN HOLLYWOOD. Quentin Tarantino's bloody drama about a washed up actor (Leonardo DiCaprio), his stuntman (Brad Pitt) and the murder of Sharon Tate (Margot Robbie). R. 165M. BROADWAY, MINOR.

OVERCOMER. Alex Kendrick writes, stars and directs the prayer-driven cross-country movie you've been waiting for. PG. 119M. BROADWAY, MILL CREEK.

PEANUT BUTTER FALCON. This moving, funny story of a pro wrestling hopeful with Down Syndrome never condescends to its characters or its audience, and Shia LaBeouf, Zack Gottsagen and Dakota Johnson give deceptively natural performances. PG13. 95M. BROADWAY, MILL CREEK.

READY OR NOT. A new bride (Samara Weaving) is hunted by her vicious, uber-wealthy in-laws as part of a ritualistic game of hide and seek in this fun, gory nail-biter with the darkest sense of humor. R. 95M. BROADWAY.

SPIDER-MAN: FAR FROM HOME EXTENDED EDITION. The extra footage better include Spidey escaping Sony. Starring Tom Holland, Jake Gyllenhall and Samuel L. Jackson. PG13. FORTUNA.

— Iridian Casarez and Jennifer Fumiko Cahill

Add a comment